Riley Gaines uses Battle of the Sexes in Venus and Serena Williams losing to ATP World No. 203 in argument against trans inclusion in sports: "They are phenoms for women"
Former NCAA swimmer Riley Gaines has been vocal about including transgender athletes in women's sports, and used the example of Venus Williams and Serena Williams losing to a lower-ranked male athlete to support her case.
Gaines was called to present her case during a June 21st hearing that dwelled on the civil rights of LGBTQ Americans, with special focus on transgender youths. After pondering whether biological male athletes have a physical advantage over biological female athletes, Gaines, a prominent advocate against the inclusion of transgender athletes in women sports, was asked to provide her opinion.
The former collegiate swimmer proceeded to recall when Serena and Venus Williams lost to then ATP World No. 203 Karsten Braasch.
"Both Serena and Venus lost to the 203rd ranked male tennis player, which, they are phenoms for women," Gaines said.
However, Human Rights Campaign president Kelley Robinson, who was on the panel, fired back by saying biological men having a physical advantage over biological women was not a 'definitive statement.'
Growing up in a household where soccer was king, my earliest memories are filled with chants from packed stadiums and the rhythm of a ball being passed across neighborhood streets. But somewhere along the way, the quiet elegance and raw emotion of tennis pulled me in. What began as a curiosity became a lifelong passion; not just for the sport itself, but for the stories it tells: of grit, of heartbreak, of improbable comebacks and human resilience.
As a tennis writer, I bring the observational lens of someone who didn’t grow up in the sport, but fell in love with it as an outsider; a perspective that lets me see both its technical beauty and its emotional depth. Over the years working with TennisUpToDate, I’ve had the privilege of reaching more than 3.5 million readers worldwide, with one of my features ranking among the site’s top three articles.
With a background in storytelling and a creative mind always searching for meaning beyond the scoreboard, I aim to craft narratives that go deeper than results and rankings. Whether it’s a rising star breaking through or a veteran fighting off Father Time, I try to capture the heartbeat behind the headlines.
.@SenJohnKennedy asks Human Rights Campaign President @KelleyJRobinson if biological males have an advantage when competing against biological women in sports. Robinson says it depends and that Sen. Kennedy would probably lose if he competed against tennis star @serenawilliams.