John McEnroe proposes replacing the fifth set with a
tie-break to speed up matches in Grand Slams. The 7-time Grand Slam champion
believes that
Wimbledon and the other majors should reduce the duration of
matches.
The former world No. 1 is ready to start broadcasting at
Wimbledon, as he will be working for the BBC during the tournament. The 3-time
SW19 champion suggested eliminating the fifth set and using a 10-point
tie-break to decide the final set.
McEnroe calls for tie-breaks to decide fifth sets
McEnroe’s proposed adjustment would eliminate up to 12 games
in the final part of the match, meaning that once players reach the fifth set,
the winner would be the first to reach 10 points with a margin of two: “I would
propose a middle ground,” McEnroe said. “That is a compromise I would start
with as opposed to going to the best of three sets.”
Another suggestion often proposed is changing the format in
the first three rounds to best-of-three sets, with best-of-five sets starting
from the round of 16. This was implemented in the first three rounds of the US
Open between 1975 and 1978, but was later abandoned: “There is something that
separates the men from the boys in a way when you play best-of-five sets
instead of best-of-three,” McEnroe said. “That’s a big change [from the regular
tour] and a big ask, so you need a combination of explosive speed and
endurance, which makes tennis that much more tricky.”
“Welcome to the world of tennis,” McEnroe said. “There are
times when there is uncertainty. There used to be more uncertainty when you
didn’t know if you would play at all if it rained and there was no roof. This
idea that playing half under the roof and half open air is a hell of a lot
better. I wish I had a roof when I played, let’s put it that way.”
John McEnroe at 1977 Wimbledon.
Wimbledon has always used the best-of-five sets format since
the first tournaments in 1877. Originally, sets did not end until a player won
at least six games with a margin of two. Tie-breaks were introduced in 1971 for
the first four sets, maintaining the two-game margin in the fifth set.
However, in recent years efforts have been made to better
address match duration. In 2010, the epic match between
John Isner and Nicolas
Mahut ended 70-68 in the fifth set after more than 11 hours. In 2019, a 7-point
tie-break was introduced when the score reached 12-12, and in 2022 it was
decided that a 10-point tie-break would be used at 6-6 in the fifth set.
The problem also lies in the fact that schedules do not
always start on time due to rain delays. Another issue is the start time on
Centre Court, which currently begins at 1:30 PM. Although some players have
requested an earlier start time, McEnroe agreed to keep it as is: “Welcome to
the world of tennis,” McEnroe said. “There are times when there is uncertainty.
There used to be more uncertainty when you didn’t know if you would play at all
if it rained and there was no roof. This idea that playing half under the roof
and half open air is a hell of a lot better. I wish I had a roof when I played,
let’s put it that way.
“The BBC, for example, and the All England Club are like,
‘Hey, sometimes people like to watch it at 8 PM or 9 PM when the ratings are
great.’ People have sat down after a long hard day at work and maybe want to
watch some tennis, so it’s not the worst thing to play into the evening. You’re
trying to find that sweet spot. It’s not always easy to get it right.”