"They are not at all at Federer's level" - Alcaraz and Sinner ranked below the 'Big Three' according to Safin
ATP
Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner are the two dominant forces in tennis in this current moment in time. However, they are still a way off the level prior generations of tennis players according to Marat Safin.
The Russian stated that the duo would not be among the best players in the world if they were competing alongside the 'Big Three.' That consisted of Roger Federer, Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic who is the only one still active.
Even the 24-time Grand Slam champion has not been able to cope with Alcaraz or Sinner, with the fact that he is not in his pomp anymore as shown at Wimbledon where Sinner defeated him once more.
The top two players have been the dominant force on the ATP Tour since 2024. They have won nine of the last 10 majors between them while constantly challenging for the biggest titles and winning them a lot of the time.
This year alone, Alcaraz took home the Australian Open title before Sinner took command by winning five consecutive Masters 1000 titles as the Spaniard evacuated to the sidelines with a wrist injury. As Sinner grows more dominant, Alcaraz will hope to get back on the court soon and continue this titanic rivalry.
Read also
Alcaraz and Sinner not on the same level as 'Big Three'
For two decades, tennis was dominated by three players who swept up almost all of the accolades in this time period. Safin, who also played alongside the likes of Federer, Nadal and Djokovic, were convinced that they were still a level above the talent that is showcased now.
"No, they are not at all at Federer's level," he said. "That's a whole different level. To reach Federer's level, they still need a lot of improvement.
"I don't want to belittle anyone. That's just my point of view. If Sinner and Alcaraz had played in the era of Nadal and Djokovic, or even in the early 2000s, they would not have been world number one or two. I don't think they would have gone that far. I think I would probably have lost to them, but I don't find them intimidating."
The two-time Grand Slam champion, who currently coaches fellow countryman Andrey Rublev, has watched these Alcaraz and Sinner play numerous times and was adamant that they were both extremely talented tennis players. "I don't know if they would have won as many Grand Slam titles in that era. I'm not sure. They are excellent players, extraordinary tennis players, and they have won many titles."

Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz are the top two tennis players on the ATP Tour
Chasing pack off the pace
He then looked down the pecking order at the players who are trying to bridge the gap over. Alexander Zverev is currently the closest to doing this but has not had great fortune on court against either of the top two. Similar to Novak Djokovic who has not spent much time on court in recent time.
Aside from those two, the likes of Felix Auger-Aliassime, Alex de Minaur, Ben Shelton, Taylor Fritz, Flavio Cobolli and Daniil Medvedev are among the players who are being left in their dust as Alcaraz and Sinner extend their lead into the distance.
Read also
Looking even further down, Safin was critical in the lack of talent on the ATP Tour compared to prior generations. "Before, there were thirty or fifty players capable of playing extraordinary tennis," he commented. "Today, there are at most ten. They reach the semifinals or final without losing a single set, and I find that almost laughable.
"Before, there were grass specialists, clay specialists, and hard court specialists. There were so many players able to compete at the highest level depending on the surface. If you look at the late 1990s or early 2000s, you see an incredible number of very strong players."

Lucas MichaelTennis Journalist
Lucas Michael is a tennis journalist based in Cambridge, UK, specializing in comprehensive coverage of the ATP and WTA tours. For the past 1.5 years, he has been a core contributor to TennisUpToDate, where he has authored more than 3,000 data-driven match reports, deep-dive analysis pieces, and engaging liveblogs.
Lucas pairs real-time statistical analysis with on-the-ground reporting, frequently traveling to tournaments to cover the action firsthand from the press box and player press conferences. This blend of advanced metrics and direct access allows him to provide sharp context regarding player form, tactical trends, and breaking tour developments.
He holds a BA (Hons) in Sports Journalism. Grounded in core journalistic ethics, Lucas places a strict emphasis on meticulous sourcing, editorial accuracy, and a commitment to updating live content swiftly as verified information emerges.
claps 0visitors 0
Just In
Popular News
Latest Comments
- I, like writer of this wonderful article, also picked Noskova to win this entire thing. I would love it if she and Andreeva are in the final.Rapunzel12-11-2026
- "Priorities", Saba... spend less time in front of cameras, anti-Social Media, selfies and back to Tennis.
mandoist12-11-2026 - Tell this to Andreeva!
mandoist12-11-2026 - Andreeva with 11 games in a row to add to Saba's downward spiral issue !!! Personal feelings aside... Jess Pegula may want to reassess her evaluation of Mirra's abilities.
mandoist12-11-2026 - I predicted whenthe list was finalised that Linda Noskova would win the WTA Finals and her matches against Gauff and Kostyuk prove that. She is the best (underrated) player in the world!Rapunzel11-11-2026
- Either Lena has a chronic internal ailment (i.e., colitis, enteritis, Crohn's, or some type of lower abdomen issue) -- or she is once again dealing with 'Vukovitis'. Mental stress can indeed cause lower body pains. No matter... whatever is truly going on sucks. "Virus" excuse is getting a bit old -- and often -- at this point.
mandoist09-11-2026 - Ironically, Martina became a U.S. Citizen about the same time as the Orange Convicted Felon & Abuser was just beginning on his road to losing all Daddy's Millions!!
mandoist09-11-2026 - "Another fresh start is in the cards." Thanks for the Humor!! I'm guessing this is the minimum one can do to keep all your sponsors hanging-on in perpetuity?
mandoist09-11-2026 - Vukov is doing this to Lena... AGAIN!!!!! WTA's autonomous collective should be dismantled for allowing Vukov to re-emerge from his hand-slapping suspension. Just ask WTA employees how that's been going lately as they witness his continued verbal abuses. Women's Pro Tennis should start over.
mandoist08-11-2026 - Can't help but suspect Vukov is back to his old self again. Thank you, WTA. Perhaps you can give them a "Battling Couple of the Year Award 2026" ??
mandoist08-11-2026







