What Brad Gilbert thinks the top 10 all time are and why Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz don't inhabit the list
ATP
For many, Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner are already the shining beacon of their generation but how do they figure in the all-time debate. Brad Gilbert, former coach of Andre Agassi and Coco Gauff among others says that while they have potential to be up on that list they aren't yet.
Gilbert spoke on Tennis Channel and said that they likely will join the list but that he currently ranks even lesser greats ahead of Sinner and Alcaraz. Sinner leads the ATP Rankings while Alcaraz is out injured but both are way ahead of the pack in terms of current wins.
In particular he said that of course the Big Three rank way ahead of Sinner and Alcaraz, but he also added other players such as Pete Sampras, Bjorn Borg, Rod Laver as well as Agassi, McEnroe, Connors and Lendl.
“Okay, provided they [Alcaraz and Sinner] both stay healthy and do a lot more, they’re going to be high up on the list. But at the moment, you know, they are not in the top 10,” he said on Tennis Channel.
Read also
“Number one, obviously, is Novak [Djokovic], Rafa [Nadal] number two, Fed [Roger Federer] number three, Pete [Sampras] four, [Bjorn] Borg five, [Rod] Laver six,” he said.
“Then seven through 10. I mean, this is heavy company, but a lot of people will mix this around. I got Andre [Agassi] at seven. I got John [McEnroe] at eight because of his insane doubles resume. I got [Jimmy] Connors at nine. I got [Ivan] Lendl at 10,”
Why Sinner and Alcaraz aren't even in top 10
But not only those players. He also ranks the likes of Mats Wilander, Boris Becker, Stefan Edberg, Ken Rosewall and John Newcombe above that. He said that neither despite recency bias are currently in that frame.
Of course this list is also missing Andy Murray who was part of the so called Big Four with Federer, Nadal and Djokovic. So where he places remains to be seen. But Sinner and Alcaraz either way don't figure on the list.
“And if you think that like oh, they should be right next to them, you still got 11 through 14-15: [Mats] Wilander, [Stefan] Edberg, [Boris] Becker, [Ken] Rosewall, [John] Newcombe, lots of guys through that first 15 for me.”

Jannik Sinner defeated Carlos Alcaraz in the 2025 ATP Finals
But he said that once they end up on double figures each and have longevity that they can be figured in that conversation down the line. They are projected to both collect more and more titles but for Gilbert as of right now. That isn't coming true.
“But once they both get to, eight to 10 and double figures [for Grand Slams] and have longevity, they will be moving up. But if they don’t, either one of them doesn’t do anything more, I can’t put them on the list.”

Samuel GillEditor-in-Chief
Samuel Gill is the Chief Content Officer (CCO) of TennisUpToDate.com, a role he has held since 2020. He is responsible for editorial governance across the platform, including setting content standards, overseeing accuracy and consistency, and guiding long-term editorial strategy. Since joining, he has contributed more than 10,000 articles and editorial pieces across the TennisUpToDate network, playing a central role in the daily operation and development of the site.
Based in Leicester, Samuel has a broad background in tennis media. In his current role, he works closely with editors and writers to ensure coverage meets clear journalistic standards, with particular attention to verification, consistency, and timely updates when new information becomes available.
claps 0visitors 0
Just In
Popular News
Latest Comments
- It's been apparent to people that remember who Saba acted and spoke (before her win streak) that she's been gradually reverting to her old nasty, argumentative, excuse-making self. Even Championships cannot hide one's personality forever.
mandoist18-11-2026 - Great list of players to watch! Really like Lilli Tagger. Nice looking game. I’m most interested in seeing how good Victoria Mboko becomes. She and Jovic and Eala might just be the ones fighting alongside Andreeva for Grand Slam titles soon.DaveyWavey16-11-2026
- Mirra's very funny words have been in my head since yesterday. "If I win the car I have 5 people in my box that can drive me around. I will forever be a passenger princess. I have a plan..." And I will never forget how she had me rolling on the floor laughing when asked how she beat Jess Pegula so handily: "I don't know what happened; It must have been the Diva in me". CLASSIC STUFF !
mandoist15-11-2026 - Can whomever has a microphone in the Final... PLEASE STOP YAMMERING ABOUT YOURSELVES NONSTOP THROUGHOUT THE MATCH???? Get a grip and STFU once in awhile so we can 'hear' the actual play on court.
mandoist15-11-2026 - Martina is one of the most competent, knowledgeable, and 99.999% correct in her analysis. Most of all -- WHILE A COMMENTATOR IN MATCHES SHE KNOWS WHEN NOT TO TALK AND DISTRACT FROM THE ACTION !!! Someone please pass that idea on to Austin, Shriver, and whoever else has been f-ing YAPPING throughout the play. How thoughtless and elitist can these people be squawking nonstop throughout an entire game about themselves. STFU, please (I said "please"). Let us 'hear' the game play on court.
mandoist15-11-2026 - Tennis "fans" have short memories. This is exactly who Saba always was... granted she found a 'new' persona when she began winning matches and tourneys. Off-court she's always been a racist potty-mouth. Her meanness also shines through when she thinks no one else is around. In short, the "person" you've witnessed in post-match on-court interviews is NOT who she is. As for her familiar "apologies, she can stick that routine in her racquet bags because I never believed her words nor phony "respect" for her opponents -- and I ain't buying that now.
mandoist15-11-2026 - Was Saba not paying attention to those who sought an inordinate amount of attention outside of their sport (occupation)... and to the point they lost their focus and eventually their place in tennis? For example: Giorgi, Bouchard, Raducanu, etc. They became infatuated with endless Selfies, videos, podcasts, TV commercials, magazine shoots, and so on. Thus their tennis suffered. Priorities are important.
mandoist14-11-2026 - I, like writer of this wonderful article, also picked Noskova to win this entire thing. I would love it if she and Andreeva are in the final.Rapunzel12-11-2026
- "Priorities", Saba... spend less time in front of cameras, anti-Social Media, selfies and back to Tennis.
mandoist12-11-2026 - Tell this to Andreeva!
mandoist12-11-2026








