Frances Tiafoe ignited headlines in his opening match at the 2025
Canadian Open after a fiery exchange with the chair umpire and a controversial finish that saw him snub the traditional post-match handshake.
The World No. 12 overcame a shaky start against Japan’s Yosuke Watanuki to secure a dramatic 1-6, 7-5, 7-6(5) comeback victory in Toronto.
However, it was not just his performance that had fans talking; it was the tense on-court scenes that unfolded between Tiafoe and veteran umpire Fergus Murphy.
The tension began in the second set, after Tiafoe received a code violation warning for audible obscenity following a passionate celebration.
The American was quick to challenge the ruling, arguing that his outburst was intended as a form of positive reinforcement rather than a breach of conduct.
Tiafoe was quick to fire back, incensed by what he believed was an unjustified warning for self-motivation.
"I don’t care. You can’t give me a code if I’m positively reinforcing myself. Doesn’t matter what I say," Tiafoe said during the on-court exchange.
Murphy stood by the ruling, replying, "It might be positive, but it’s still offensive… it might be positive to you, but other people would get offended with that word. I’m explaining, that’s the rule.".
Not satisfied, Tiafoe doubled down on the sarcasm, launching into a pointed monologue:
"I love you brother. You do a great job up there man. You really do. Honestly, I’m happy how long your tenure’s been. It’s incredible. I love having you up there. You’re excellent, excellent. Incredible stuff man. Carry on.".
Later in the match, Tiafoe hit a ball into the stands in frustration, but this time, Murphy let it slide without further penalties. That call, or lack of one, may have kept Tiafoe in the match.
Additionally, the post-match handshake, or lack thereof, added another twist. After the final point, Tiafoe initially extended his hand toward Murphy, who responded in kind. But in a sudden change of heart, the American pulled away, choosing not to follow through with the traditional gesture of sportsmanship.
Yet even the American later acknowledged that Murphy could have issued a game penalty that might have changed the outcome.
"You could’ve got me out of here, at least game penalty. I’m saying I appreciate it. You understood the time," Tiafoe said in a surprisingly reflective moment.
To which Murphy replied, "You have to get the balance right, Frances.".
Tiafoe will now face
Aleksandar Vukic in the third round. Vukic, who upset British star
Cameron Norrie in three sets, 6-3, 6-7(2), 6-3, will be looking to repeat his success against the American after beating him in their previous tour-level meeting at the 2024
Almaty Open.
If Tiafoe levels their head-to-head record with a win, he could next face either Christopher O’Connell or the winner of the match between
Alex de Minaur and
Francisco Comesana in the fourth round.
Beyond that, possible quarterfinal clashes could see him square off against rising stars
Ben Shelton or
Flavio Cobolli, with heavyweights
Taylor Fritz or
Andrey Rublev potentially waiting in the semifinals.
Nevertheless, some viewers saw it as a symbolic protest against what Tiafoe viewed as unfair officiating, while others slammed the gesture as unsportsmanlike and disrespectful.
The incident has sparked widespread debate online, with fans and commentators questioning whether emotional players should be held to higher standards or whether chair umpires, like Murphy, should show more leniency in tense, high-stakes matches.
As discussion rages across platforms like X (formerly Twitter) and TikTok, the clip of Tiafoe’s half-hearted handshake has already racked up hundreds of thousands of views, fueling broader conversations about behaviour, bias, and accountability in the sport.
For better or worse, Frances Tiafoe isn’t just advancing at the Canadian Open; he is dominating the headlines.