“Would you want to watch that?”: John McEnroe and Maria Sharapova split on five-set women’s matches
Tennis News
John McEnroe and Maria Sharapova discussed the future structure of Grand Slam tennis during an appearance on the Rushmore podcast, reopening a long-running debate about whether match formats should be altered. The conversation centred on the possibility of best-of-five-set matches in women’s tennis and potential adjustments to deciding sets in the men’s game.
The discussion quickly exposed a clear divergence in views between the two former world No. 1 players. Sharapova expressed immediate scepticism about extending women’s matches to five sets, questioning both the competitive logic and spectator appeal of such a change at the highest level of the sport.
McEnroe, meanwhile, adopted a more experimental stance, referencing past trials of extended formats in women’s tennis and suggesting that structural innovation should remain on the table. His comments focused less on tradition and more on finding a compromise between entertainment value and competitive integrity.
The exchange ultimately moved beyond the specific question of women’s five-set finals, touching on broader concerns about physical demands in men’s matches and whether modern tennis could benefit from modified scoring systems designed to reduce match length while preserving competitive tension.
Read also
Women’s five-set debate and Sharapova’s resistance
Sharapova was directly asked about the prospect of women’s finals being played as best-of-five sets, mirroring the men’s Grand Slam format. Her response was unequivocal, framing the idea as both impractical and commercially unappealing from a viewing perspective.
The Russian argued that extending matches would not necessarily improve the product for fans, questioning the underlying assumption that longer automatically means better. “Why would they do that? Would you want to watch that? Watching a women's match best-of-five from start to finish? No chance. I don't believe it.”
Sharapova’s position also implicitly raised concerns about scheduling, recovery, and the consistency of performance across longer matches, although she did not expand on those aspects in detail during the exchange.
McEnroe responded by pointing to historical precedent, noting that extended formats had already been tested in elite women’s tennis. “They already did it for a few years with the women at Madison Square Garden, at the tournament featuring the top eight players. I think Martina Navratilova and Monica Seles played best-of-five matches, and it wasn't a total disaster.”
McEnroe’s compromise idea: reshaping the deciding set
While acknowledging that longer matches do not automatically guarantee higher quality, McEnroe shifted the discussion towards structural compromise. His focus was on maintaining the competitive stakes of five-set tennis while reducing physical strain and match duration.
He compared sporting endurance to entertainment formats, suggesting that extended duration can sometimes dilute quality rather than enhance it. “It wasn't necessarily more competitive. Often, a two-hour movie is better than a three-and-a-half-hour movie. Men's stamina drops too. Very often in fifth sets, both players are exhausted.”
McEnroe then outlined a specific proposal aimed at preserving the tension of a deciding set while introducing a faster resolution mechanism. The idea would maintain best-of-five structure but replace the traditional fifth set with a shortened decider. “I think there should be best-of-five matches, but with a 10-point super tie-break when it's two sets all. It would be a sort of compromise.”
Cristhián AvilaTennis Journalist
Cristhián Ávila is a tennis journalist based in Santiago, Chile, and has been part of the TennisUpToDate team since early 2023. He covers the ATP and WTA Tours as well as all four Grand Slams, producing breaking news, match reports, analysis, and regular liveblogs from major tournaments.
His reporting combines statistical analysis with clear explanation, helping readers understand tactical developments, player form, and broader storylines across the tour. Working fluently in both Spanish and English, Cristhián collaborates with an international editorial team and contributes to comprehensive global coverage. As part of his work, he has conducted interviews and media interactions with leading figures in the sport, including Caroline Wozniacki and John McEnroe.
In his journalism, Cristhián places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles promptly when new, verified information becomes available. His coverage is grounded in research, context, and direct engagement with professional tennis.
claps 0visitors 0
Just In
Popular News
Latest Comments
- I, like writer of this wonderful article, also picked Noskova to win this entire thing. I would love it if she and Andreeva are in the final.Rapunzel12-11-2026
- "Priorities", Saba... spend less time in front of cameras, anti-Social Media, selfies and back to Tennis.
mandoist12-11-2026 - Tell this to Andreeva!mandoist12-11-2026
- Andreeva with 11 games in a row to add to Saba's downward spiral issue !!! Personal feelings aside... Jess Pegula may want to reassess her evaluation of Mirra's abilities.mandoist12-11-2026
- I predicted whenthe list was finalised that Linda Noskova would win the WTA Finals and her matches against Gauff and Kostyuk prove that. She is the best (underrated) player in the world!Rapunzel11-11-2026
- Either Lena has a chronic internal ailment (i.e., colitis, enteritis, Crohn's, or some type of lower abdomen issue) -- or she is once again dealing with 'Vukovitis'. Mental stress can indeed cause lower body pains. No matter... whatever is truly going on sucks. "Virus" excuse is getting a bit old -- and often -- at this point.mandoist09-11-2026
- Ironically, Martina became a U.S. Citizen about the same time as the Orange Convicted Felon & Abuser was just beginning on his road to losing all Daddy's Millions!!mandoist09-11-2026
- "Another fresh start is in the cards." Thanks for the Humor!! I'm guessing this is the minimum one can do to keep all your sponsors hanging-on in perpetuity?mandoist09-11-2026
- Vukov is doing this to Lena... AGAIN!!!!! WTA's autonomous collective should be dismantled for allowing Vukov to re-emerge from his hand-slapping suspension. Just ask WTA employees how that's been going lately as they witness his continued verbal abuses. Women's Pro Tennis should start over.mandoist08-11-2026
- Can't help but suspect Vukov is back to his old self again. Thank you, WTA. Perhaps you can give them a "Battling Couple of the Year Award 2026" ??mandoist08-11-2026
