"When you announce retirement, you should retire" - McEnroe against Federer and Serena Williams making a comeback
Williams was greeted by emotional scenes and messages of farewell when she seemingly stepped away from tennis at the US Open last month, but hasn't completely ruled out a return instead saying she would be “evolving away” from the sport.
"I'd literally have to sell my house" - Tennis fans shocked by exorbitant Laver Cup prices following Federer's retirement announcement
Federer is set to be greeted by similar scenes on Friday when he plays his final doubles match at Friday's Laver Cup in London. McEnroe, who won seven Grand Slam titles, retired from singles action in 1992 but has continued to play the odd exhibition match and on the ATP Champions Tour. He also played doubles in the ATP Tour in 2006.
The controversial Amercian has said it is best for the sport if Federer and Williams say their final goodbyes to competitive action. "Both of these superstars and legends can do whatever they want," he told Eurosport.
"To me when you announce retirement, you should retire, or whatever. But then you look at other athletes and they come back, and then you think 'hey I just played well I can still win' so that's really up to them.
"I've had to hear it for the last 25 years" - John McEnroe on people saying he'd have lost to Serena Williams in a tennis match
"On the one hand I think they're ready to move on, but then it's so difficult to do that because it's such a big part of your life. Then if they did come back you wouldn't hold it against them. Of course we want to see them play forever, but it feels like when you make those type of announcements it's right to say 'this is the way it should end'. I think it would be better for all concerned.
“Serena's thing was amazing at the US Open. I've got a feeling this is going to be incredible for Roger, I think he's ready.”
Federer looks unlikely to go back on his retirement decision after struggling with a knee injury for the last three years. He is only playing one doubles match at the Laver Cup in his farewell tournament.